“Terrorists Get Their Close-Up”
Immediately after 9/11–when seeing anything other than evil behind terrorism got Bill Maher and Susan Sontag lambasted–there was a limited audience in the U.S. for complex terrorists. But four years and a controversial war later, a few works are starting to hang flesh on those stick villains. In addition to Syriana and Sleeper Cell, there’s The War Within, a film about a plan to blow up New York City’s Grand Central Terminal, and Paradise Now, about Palestinian suicide bombers. Salman Rushdie has taken up the subject in his latest novel, Shalimar the Clown.
“We saw our roles as artists as touching the audience in a way beneath the hardened political rhetoric,” says Ayad Akhtar, who co-wrote and stars (in his debut lead performance) in War Within. His character, Hassan, is a Pakistani who plans, coldly, to blow himself up. But he falls in love, is touched by suffering and speaks passionately about his cause. That, Akhtar recognizes, is a treacherous balance. “As an actor, I very much approached this as a portrayal of a suicide,” he says. “As filmmakers, we always had to keep in mind that this was an act of murder.”
Perhaps because of the tricky moral ground–and the potential for bolstering stereotypes–those terrorism scripts include sympathetic Muslims as audience surrogates. In Syriana there is a reformist Arab prince; in War Within, Hassan’s childhood friend Sayeed (Firdous Bamji), an assimilated suburban dad, doesn’t understand why Hassan can’t leave his anger and piety back in the Old World. In its sweeping, 24-like thriller plot, Sleeper Cell depicts a wide range of extremists but also Darwyn (Michael Ealy), a devout Muslim FBI agent who infiltrates the cell and sees its members as foes of Islam.
The motives of the terrorists vary, from war atrocities to personal woes; in Rushdie’s novel a Kashmiri Muslim murders a U.S. ambassador, but it’s less a political act than payback for a personal betrayal. Often U.S. actions play a role. War Within’s Hassan is radicalized after American agents snatch him in Paris as a terrorism suspect and send him to Pakistan to be tortured.
— James Poniewozik